Malawi has seen off a K233 billion claim after the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights threw out a case brought by South African businessman Patroklos Tsaperas, a director of Malawi Mobile Limited. In a ruling in Arusha on 13 November, the court said he had filed the case far too late, so it never decided whether Malawi violated his rights.
“We have won the Tsaperas v Malawi case,” Attorney General Frank Mbeta told Nyasa Times.
Key facts
- Claim: K233 billion (US$133.7 million), plus K697 million in licence fee refunds and K2.1 billion in legal costs, Nyasa Times reported
- Filed 7 years, 7 months and 7 days after Malawi’s Supreme Court ruling, which the court called “unjustified and excessive”
- The court did not rule on whether Malawi violated his rights
- Each side pays its own costs
How the dispute started
Why the case failed
Malawi argued that Tsaperas waited too long. The court agreed: he was not in prison, not short of money and had lawyers throughout, yet gave no reason for the wait. Because a case must meet every admissibility condition, the court did not look at the others.
On the other preliminary points, the court said it could hear cases against Malawi, which accepted its jurisdiction in 2008. It accepted that his property claim had been through Malawi’s courts, through the company’s own case, but said his other complaints, including discrimination, had not.








